European listed real estate industry sounds alarm at German regulator’s targeting of REITs for AIFMD rules – EPRA
Brussels, April 11 – EPRA has voiced alarm at an unexpected proposal by Germany’s Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) to include domestic REITs within the scope of the EU’s Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD) as it is applied under German law. BaFin invited interested stakeholders to submit their views on the AIFMD by an April 12 deadline.
The AIFMD is a European Union regulation which brings “investment funds” under the supervision of an EU regulatory body. According to EPRA, the new compliance rules applicable under the incoming regime are unlikely to be too much of a concern for the already highly regulated publicly quoted REITs, but it is the potential classification of these listed real estate companies as part of the fund sector that is of most concern.
Philip Charls, EPRA CEO, said: “The G-REITs in existence today are essentially the same as other German corporate businesses with their focus being to operate in the commercial property sector. To reclassify them as ‘funds’ is not only the wrong conclusion and contrary to the objectives of the AIFMD, but would, if implemented, be detrimental to the future growth of the German listed property sector and the efficiency of the broader domestic real estate industry - and so too its critical role in supporting the German economy.”
EPRA strongly opposes key aspects of the BaFin proposals. Firstly, the proposal that corporate companies with G-REIT (German REIT) status should be included within the AIFMD and secondly, the regulator’s view that the business of developing, refurbishing, owning and managing property for the long term is not a commercial operating business.
According to EPRA, the confusion between REITs and real estate funds comes because the underlying business activities of both can be broadly similar. However, the industry association’s view is that the critical identifying features of a fund -- as opposed to commercial operating businesses -- arises from the relationship and engagement with its investors. In this respect, the relationship between a REIT and its shareholders and the operation of the corporation is no different to any other publicly listed company – whether in the real estate sector or not.
G-REITs are perpetual operating companies and simply have a business strategy with the flexibility to be changed from time to time by their management, attracting a positive or negative reaction from shareholders and the market in general. REITs worldwide develop and operate property as long-term businesses with constantly evolving strategies. Their corporate structures and business operating models convey unique attributes that set them apart from the fund sector and have been proven to deliver significant benefits to the quality of the built environment in other developed markets around the globe.
Gareth Lewis, EPRA Finance Director, said: “Germany has one of the smallest listed property market of any major economy globally and EPRA believes that if BaFin insists in reclassifying G-REITs as funds, it will be forcing these businesses into a sector where they don’t belong – nullifying the unique attributes that a healthy listed property sector brings and limiting the future growth of the Germany listed real estate industry. This will have real social and economic implications for Germany in areas ranging from job creation, to investment and development in its cities and particularly sustainability – where listed property companies are leading the way in cutting energy and water consumption and managing waste in buildings across Europe.”
For more information, contact Gareth Lewis: firstname.lastname@example.org
EPRA welcomes BaFin's revised position that G-REITs should be assessed against the criteria for identifying funds in the same way as any other real estate company. This reflects the recent guidance provided by the European Securities and Markets Authority and supports EPRA's view.
EPRA has voiced alarm at an unexpected proposal by Germany’s Supervisory Authority BaFin to include domestic REITs within the scope of the EU’s AIFMD. The potential classification of listed real estate companies as part of the 'fund' sector is of most concern.
"If implemented, it would be detrimental to the future growth of the German listed property sector, the efficiency of the broader domestic real estate industry and hit the wider economy." EPRA.
Assets under management of real estate securities funds grew 68% to USD 250 billion from 2007 to 2012. Real estate securities funds increased 39% to 677 in the same period. Why? “Above-average dividend yields and secure long-term cashflows generated by listed real estate companies." Convincing new research evidence suggests that having listed real estate in a portfolio can also improve returns and diversify risk.
We look at the wave of new REIT legislation taking shape in Europe, and consider how the German listed property sector could well double in size over the coming two years. The predicament faced by savers is explore, and the how 'listed' can fit their needs. How could regulation generate new REIT waves in European corporate real estate? What is current thinking on the cost and transparency of listed investment allocations?
AIFMD regulatory clarity for real estate welcomed
EPRA has broadly welcomed the approach taken by ESMA in its recent consultation covering key concepts of the AIFM Directive. Our strong view is that listed property companies and REITs are commercial operating businesses, not funds, and should therefore fall outside of the scope of the AIFMD.
Ireland and Spain on the REIT course
Spain and Ireland, the two eurozone countries worst affected by real estate crises that have damaged their banking systems and plunged their economies into recession, are, despite very different approaches to dealing with their property problems, both implementing new REIT regimes in 2013, the European Public Real Estate Association (EPRA) said. Madrid and Dublin see real estate investment trusts listed on the equities markets as one of the most effective and transparent ways of recapitalizing their property sectors.
Property stocks outperforming direct real estate on all fronts, first global pensions study shows
Pension funds worldwide are on average getting poorer performance, higher costs, less transparency and liquidity by investing directly in bricks and mortar or using funds to do so. New research find that opting for property stocks, and particularly the efficient listed Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) structure, is the way forward.
Europe's financial crisis bears parallels to US 1990's Savings & Loans - possible listed RE role in solution
Europe’s financial crisis has some striking similarities to the US Saving & Loan real estate debt problems of the early 1990s, and a major contribution to its solution may similarly lie in repackaging distressed property assets into attractive listed vehicles for investors - EPRA reseach suggests.
Case strengthened for pension fund allocation shift to listed real estate stock
The most conclusive evidence to-date that institutional investors can achieve the same diversification benefits of real estate as an asset class by increasing the proportion of listed real estate in their portfolios. All with the additional benefits of greater liquidity and lower costs say two independent research studies.
EU should prioritise listed property for Growth & Green
The EU may be able to achieve the biggest pay-offs in its key twin policy goals of boosting growth and cutting the bloc’s energy consumption by 20% by 2020, through harnessing the economic power of Europe’s real estate industry and channelling financing through the transparent and efficient listed property sector. By prioritising the listed sector, the EU would give a large boost to its chances of meeting its targets and lifting economic growth at the same time.
Solution to Spain's real estate crisis may lie in US Savings & Loan REIT model
European REITs satisfy thirst for dividend yields
High investor demand for dividend yield, against a background of weak equity markets and ultra-low interest rates, can be met by income flows from European listed property companies and particularly REITs, new EPRA research shows.
Dividend yields from the sector have remained consistently above equities and bond yields over the past five years.
Real estate equities’ performance outshines non-listed options for investors in Germany
The lack of a large, dynamic, listed corporate real estate sector in Germany, comparable with neighbouring economies, appears to have curtailed investor returns over the long-term by limiting their property investment options. EPRA findings conclude that the restrictions on the development of a vibrant listed German real estate sector appear to have cost investors dearly in terms of long-term property investment performance. More >>
Listed property sector plays vital role in economic recovery says new EPRA chairman.
David Atkins, CEO of UK property company Hammerson, has been appointed as Chairman of the European Public Real Estate Association. Speaking at the industry body’s annual conference (Sept 2011), he said that the key role listed property firms play in European economies, mean they are vital to a sustainable economic recovery.More >>
EXECUTIVE SUMMARIES OF RESEARCH